Best Lens ?

Alpha
Posts
17,417
Likes
164,457
Have a Canon EOS 550D and wonder if anyone has advice on a good lens for taking watch pics ?
Not looking to spend a fortune, 99% of spare cash is reserved for watch purchases.
Also any advice for a novice watch snapper appreciated.
 
alam
Posts
8,234
Likes
19,415
any lens....... from Nikon 馃榿
 
alam
Posts
8,234
Likes
19,415
Alpha Alpha
Have a Canon EOS 550D and wonder if anyone has advice on a good lens for taking watch pics ?
Not looking to spend a fortune, 99% of spare cash is reserved for watch purchases.
Also any advice for a novice watch snapper appreciated.

"Fortune" is relative - a true macro lens like the Canon EF-S 60mm f/2.8 Macro will set you back ~$400. But this lens will give you a very short minimum focusing distance (7.5") - if compare that with the minimum focusing distance of a typical normal lens (45-55mm) of 1'.5". Most true macro lenses give a 1:1 maximum magnification.

You have other more economical options, like close up lens adapters (from Hoya or Cokin) - you basically screw these in front of your normal lens to achieve a greater magnification - you will pay a lot less for these ($40-130) lenses but you should expect less picture quality. The minimum focusing distance from these varies and is dependent on the close up lens and the main lens that you use. Your other option is to get a true macro lens from a third party company like Sigma and that will save you a few dollars from a Canon lens (~$340).
 
kyle L
Posts
4,449
Likes
11,333
alam alam
A "fortune" is relative - but a true Canon macro lens like the Canon EF-S 60mm f/2.8 Macro will set you back ~$400. This lens gives you a very short minimum focusing distance (7.5") - compare that with the minimum focusing distance of a typical normal lens (45-55mm) of 1'.5". Most true macro lenses give a 1:1 maximum magnification.

That would be my recommendation as well, I love that lens. Here's one that I took with the Rebel Xsi and the 60mm:

8103054629_67c0623aa3_b.jpg
 
alam
Posts
8,234
Likes
19,415
kyle L kyle L
That would be my recommendation as well, I love that lens. Here's one that I took with the Rebel Xsi and the 60mm:

8103054629_67c0623aa3_b.jpg

馃憤 Not shabby at all for being a Canon system.... 馃榿
 
U
Posts
25,980
Likes
27,689
alam alam
馃憤 Not shabby at all for being a Canon system.... 馃榿

Easy now, I use a Canon P & S G9. Most times it's on full automatic.
 
Alpha
Posts
17,417
Likes
164,457
Kyle, now that is what I would hope to achieve, eventually.
Great opinions guys, more please.
Santa list for Mrs 馃槈
 
Alpha
Posts
17,417
Likes
164,457
Canon EF-S 60mm f/2.8 Macro
Thank you guys for your advice, a little research, not that I ever doubted you and that is the fella for me.
 
pascs
Posts
1,661
Likes
5,849
I've been thinking of a macro lens for my wife's Canon 400D. Its currently fitted with a Canon EFS 18-55mm which seems ok for general pics but isnt great at close up. Would the EFS 60mm f/2.8 Macro be a worthwhile addition? the picture from Kyle looks amazing using that lens.

I see there are plenty of 2nd hand ones on ebay, I assume its ok to buy a 'lightly used' 2nd hand one?

..............think my wife needs a Christmas present 馃槈
 
Alpha
Posts
17,417
Likes
164,457
These girls sure are lucky, that's at least two with camera equipment for christmas.
If mine is really lucky she may get a new watch, although it will be quite masculine in style. 馃憤
 
MSNWatch
Posts
6,641
Likes
11,453
I use a tamron 180mm macro attached to a nikon dslr. Every watch pic obviously shot with a tripod. The longer focal length just works for the fairly standard way I take watch pictures. The shorter prime macro lenses even those made by a third party should be equally superb.
 
Alpha
Posts
17,417
Likes
164,457
I think the magic word is "Tripod" I have to admit that I only used to use the tripod out of doors but since using it for watch shots I have seen a marked improvement 馃憤
 
cicindela
Posts
15,048
Likes
24,051
Alpha Alpha
I think the magic word is "Tripod" I have to admit that I only used to use the tripod out of doors but since using it for watch shots I have seen a marked improvement 馃憤
And the sturdier ($$) the better. A cheap tripod will transmit a lot of vibration.
 
Mary255
Posts
153
Likes
19
I have an opposite problem: The watch photos appear to be too sharp - showing sorry blemishes that I do not see with my bare eyes. Certainly one would not want to show those images without softening them if one wants to sell the watch, right? To me that would present an unfair "reality" of the watch.

How do you deal with this problem? Or is it a problem?
 
U
Posts
25,980
Likes
27,689
Mary255 Mary255
I have an opposite problem: The watch photos appear to be too sharp - showing sorry blemishes that I do not see with my bare eyes. Certainly one would not want to show those images without softening them if one wants to sell the watch, right? To me that would present an unfair "reality" of the watch.

How do you deal with this problem? Or is it a problem?

Buy watches in better condition or get your perscription checked. 馃槣

Macro photography brings out imperfections invisible to the naked eye and we do want to see every blemish.
 
Mary255
Posts
153
Likes
19
U ulackfocus
Buy watches in better condition or get your perscription checked. 馃槣

Macro photography brings out imperfections invisible to the naked eye and we do want to see every blemish.
The problem is I think you would see blemishes even on a new watch.
 
U
Posts
25,980
Likes
27,689
Mary255 Mary255
The problem is I think you would see blemishes even on a new watch.

Yes, you can - under high enough magnification. 10X loupes should be outlawed from this hobby.
 
dsio
Posts
33,160
Likes
37,892
U ulackfocus
Yes, you can - under high enough magnification. 10X loupes should be outlawed from this hobby.
Those pictures of the Zenith El Primero someone posted under a microscope make it look like it was hacked together in someone's basement.
 
LouS
Posts
6,712
Likes
18,569
dsio dsio
Those pictures of the Zenith El Primero someone posted under a microscope make it look like it was hacked together in someone's basement.

It might have been - it was a gray market piece from amazon. His later examination of one from an AD was a whole different story.
 
20 More Posts...
Sign up or log in to reply...