The Grand Seiko Guy... any opinions?

Posts
442
Likes
1,924
That's my whole point. I leave room in the universe for the possibility that this poster may have neglected to tell us about an actual deal gone wrong taking place after being denied his demands, but nothing that he has written so far strikes me as proof that The Grand Seiko Guy is some kind of con artist.
 
Posts
1,308
Likes
5,723
Hey so I made this account strictly to spread the word about this scammer. The only thread / forum where I could find people discussing his credibility. I reached out for a watch, he demanded I send him money through a direct money wire to his bank account in Thailand. I asked for him to go through a legitimate site such as chrono24, hodinkee, eBay, or even just use PayPal but he said no because he only deals with clients who trust him. I asked him to prove he was trust worthy and he sent me back that he was part of a Facebook group for grand seikos, and he had done some podcasts lately. That was it he had no testimonials and wasn't willing to do a secure transaction. This should have been the ultimate red flag for me. Also his Instagram account was taken down for breaking the community guidelines on business integrity. Please help spread the word about this scammer. I am trying my best to save others but there aren't many places to reach out to.
In your explanation you don't say he actually scammed you. Did he? Did you lose money or were you only afraid that you would?
 
Posts
4
Likes
0
So let me get this straight: you did not complete any deal with him because he wouldn't bend to your demands to do what you consider to be a secure transaction. Is that correct? And yet, you feel entitled to brand him as a "fraud" and a "scammer" without giving him the benefit of the doubt?

Unless I have misunderstood your post, I believe you are seriously out of line. Any seller is free to choose the rules under which he is willing to complete a transaction. Given these constraints, any buyer is free to abide by these terms or give up on the deal. Just because he declined to agree to your own terms doesn't necessarily make him malevolent or untrustworthy. And it certainly shouldn't expose him to libel from someone like you.

Feel free to correct my perception if it is false or incomplete, but I am genuinely shocked at your inquisition-like haste to demolish one man's reputation simply based on your perception of what should be acceptable or not.
No you're completely wrong. I sent him over 2000 after he wouldn't budge and haven't received any response or watch in 2 weeks. You sound like you could be him the way your defensive about it. Like I said I'm spreading awareness for others to not fall for it. Nothing else to it.
This seems worthy of watching unfold.
 
Posts
743
Likes
2,539
Gerald has a good reputation in the vintage Seiko community for being an authority on vintage Grand Seiko and for selling only well-researched, all original vintage watches. I'd be very surprised if he's done something wrong.
 
Posts
23,131
Likes
51,634
No you're completely wrong. I sent him over 2000 after he wouldn't budge and haven't received any response or watch in 2 weeks. You sound like you could be him the way your defensive about it. Like I said I'm spreading awareness for others to not fall for it. Nothing else to it.

I doubt anyone is going to take your wild claims seriously without some really compelling proof. This expert and seller has been around for a long time, and I've never heard anything negative before. You are an anonymous new member with an unusual approach and no credibility. If there is any truth in your story, document your claims and contact the authorities.
 
Posts
442
Likes
1,924
No you're completely wrong. I sent him over 2000 after he wouldn't budge and haven't received any response or watch in 2 weeks.
You may wish to start with that point then, before bitching about how his terms of sales are not to your liking. And if I was mean, I would then question why you decided to send money to someone you saw as unbending and unreasonable...

Anyway, while the absence of response is definitely concerning, two weeks is a very short time for the worldwide shipping situation these days, especially in this season. So unless this was a domestic dispatch, I still see your current behaviour as an overreaction whose effects may result in an undeserved stain on someone's reputation.

What happens if the watch shows up at your door tomorrow? Will you take the time to retract your accusations and fall on your sword?
 
Posts
658
Likes
3,172
Fraudster and scammer do not send money or trust this man. I recently got scammed the hard way.
I wonder if the moderators will not intervene here. Here comes a completely unknown guy around the corner and accuses a long-time respected collector of fraud without even bringing a single piece of evidence. This is damaging to the reputation and should be dealt with immediately.

To be honest, I am quite shocked that something like this is possible here.
 
Posts
13,459
Likes
52,945
Oh …Grand Seiko guy thread resuscitated. More positive thoughts expected. Instead some random dude trashing a guy who most folks think is just fine.
 
Posts
23,131
Likes
51,634
I wonder if the moderators will not intervene here. Here comes a completely unknown guy around the corner and accuses a long-time respected collector of fraud without even bringing a single piece of evidence. This is damaging to the reputation and should be dealt with immediately.

To be honest, I am quite shocked that something like this is possible here.

Let's see how it plays out, I don't think you'd want the moderators to step in immediately every time someone makes a complaint or allegation. As noted already, without evidence, nobody will take the allegations seriously.
 
Posts
2,656
Likes
5,352
I have had no personal or business dealings with The Grand Seiko Guy, but I have visited his website for research and learned quite a lot from his scholarly articles and IG posts. He offers a monthly subscription service for a very modest fee one gets reviews of YahooJapan auctions and also preview announcements of upcoming sales and subscriber discounts on his watches for sale. As a vintage GS is high on my wish list I plan to subscribe to the site I view this as a totally legitimate business model, much like others in vintage watch business who offer Patreon memberships which provide similar arrangements for small monthly fee.
Nothing in this thread has convinced me to not join or to not consider buying a GS watch from The Grand Seiko Guy. The new poster has made serious and as yet unsubstantiated allegations which are not credible at this point. Does such behaviour warrant removal from OF? Moderators?
 
Posts
391
Likes
945
I was one of the people posting positively about Gerald earlier in this thread. That was 2018.

In the past 4 years I have continued dealing with him, including where I received money, not just where I paid money. And he is 100% honest, reliable, trustworthy, knowledgeable... the list of positives could go on but you get the point.

And hey I'm wearing a Seiko today so may as well post it.